Letter to the Editor

New ghost town?

Tuesday, August 26, 2008

Dear Editor,

If recent information wasn't a 2x4 between the eyes of city government, it sure should have been.

First is sales tax collections. To use this is to determine the health of the local economy is like determining the depth of the lake by looking at the surface.

In July of this year the city received $123,950 compared to $121,895 for the same period last year. That $2,055 increase is a mere 1.7 percent increase.

During that year, natural gas rates have risen 25 percent, electric rates 10 percent and water and sewer 10 percent. All of these are subject to sales tax and by themselves should have made the increase far more than 1.7 percent.

Prices of many goods subject to sales tax have also risen drastically. Copper pipe and wire up 50 percent, carpet up 18 percent, plastic products up 15 to 20 percent, shingles, vinyl siding, etc., etc., all up.

Looking beyond the surface, these facts lead to the conclusion that sales volume actually declines a year ago by 10 to 15 percent.

Since 2000, I count a net loss of at least 11 businesses: a grocery store, a jewelry store, two used car dealers, My Favorite Things, Ben Franklin, a buffet restaurant, a fabric store, Amy's Fashions, a modular home dealer, a coin dealer, Redman's Shoes, Radio Shack, Auto Zone, Blockbuster, Carpet King and two fewer convenience stores. We've gained two cellular phone stores, Garrison's, Game On, Fastenal, Joltin' Joe's and a liquor store. A new owner and / or a new name for a business that existed previously is not a gain!

Other disturbing news is that McCook's population has declined by 500 folks since 2000. City hall says says it's no big deal ... I say it's a VERY big deal. That's over a 6 percent decline. Six percent fewer customers for our merchants. Permit me to put it in perspective. If each of those 500 folks bought fast food twice a week, that's 52,000 fewer sales a year ... probably a loss of sales for 1,000 pairs of shoes. That decline trickles through every single phase of our local economy.

I know of 16 people who have left McCook since the 2000 census. How many can you name?

Fact is, had there not been hyper-inflation of many products subject to sales tax, revenues received by the city would have declines.

The population loss and the loss of merchants are the two most important issues facing the city. They must be addressed aggressively by spending our money to reverse these trends.

Ghost towns don't need walking trails nor a city hall.

'Nuff said.

Bill Frasier,

McCook

Comments
View 10 comments
Note: The nature of the Internet makes it impractical for our staff to review every comment. Please note that those who post comments on this website may do so using a screen name, which may or may not reflect a website user's actual name. Readers should be careful not to assign comments to real people who may have names similar to screen names. Refrain from obscenity in your comments, and to keep discussions civil, don't say anything in a way your grandmother would be ashamed to read.
  • I agree that the decline of population in McCook and all SW Nebraska is concerning. The loss of 500 people from the 2000 census is an ESTIMATE. The same folks that made that estimate were the ones that a few years back said McCook would be at 10,000 by the year 2000. The new half cent sales tax is an effort to attract, expand and retain businesses and people to our area. I also agree that I can name 16 people that have left the community since 2000 BUT I can also name 16 people that have joined the community. I doubt that letters to the editor that are critical of the community will help attract new folks to town but maybe I am wrong about that.

    -- Posted by dennis on Tue, Aug 26, 2008, at 3:05 PM
  • Well said, Bill. It's amazing how our City Government can say that McCook is doing fine, yet so many citizens are struggling. Everything is going up as stated, except for the incomes. A 3% cost of living increase that most employers give doesn't cover the natural gas, electric and sewage rates. How do we get ahead? Yes, McCook is slowly becoming a ghost town and it's sad. The surplus the City has that they don't know what to do with should be given back to the citizens in some manner to assist with the cost of increases in their rates.

    -- Posted by FNLYHOME on Tue, Aug 26, 2008, at 4:02 PM
  • Why of course any census is an estimate, what are they suppose to do go door to door and take a head count?? I for one and anyone else that has lived in McCook since 2000 can tell you that the population has declined. To be honest I think the 500 loss is a very conservative figure. Bill hit it right on the head. Instead of finding ways to spend our tax money the City Council needs to be finding way's to bring people back to McCook. Keep up the good work Bill.

    -- Posted by remington81 on Tue, Aug 26, 2008, at 4:06 PM
  • I agree with Dennis on a number of points, and agree with his statement about the negative letters, I do not agree with some of the spending being proposed, especially the new city hall/safety center! Put it to a vote before wasting $500,000. I think we have many more important places to use the money, streets for one! Seems like Mr. Frasier likes to write negative letters most of time. But I guess everyone enjoys "stirring the pot" once in awhile.

    -- Posted by goarmy67 on Tue, Aug 26, 2008, at 10:18 PM
  • The $500,000 reserve has already been tapped to help reduce sewer/water costs plus other projects. There is no 500K stashed away for a new safety center/city offices but it would probably be wise to set a little aside each year so if/when the project goes foreward the bond would not need to be so high and if there is a bond there will need to be a vote so no need to get the cart before the horse.

    -- Posted by dennis on Wed, Aug 27, 2008, at 1:34 PM
  • I am one of those 500 people that left McCook recently. I attribute our move 70 miles to the North to the fact that there are absolutely no jobs in the area nor any that pay well or provide any decent benefits. We left McCook due to my husband getting a much better job with higher pay and awesome benefits. I also must say that there is absolutely nothing in McCook for the young people to do, other than get into trouble. The parks are horribly run down and under maintained. The equipment is just as run down and unmaintained at Norris Park, the pride of the town. We left because EVERYTHING seem to be going up and there was no relief in sight for the residence of McCook. I agree that the town is slowly becoming a ghost town and it is no fault but that of the city council. Way to go guys, soon enough there will be nobody to "council". You all need to focus on what is needed to keep people in the area instead of what will make the "upper crust" happy!

    -- Posted by FormerMcCookie on Thu, Aug 28, 2008, at 11:36 AM
  • Dear Former, McCook has one of the lowest unemployment rates in the state. The paper is full of help wanted ads each day and employers are struggling to find workers. I am happy for you and your family that you found a better job in North Platte, even though they have higher taxes than McCook. I agree that the playground equipment in Norris Park needs updated. Maybe that is why the city council put $10,000 aside for improvements this budget year. I do not understand your complaint that kids have nothing to do in McCook. One of the pluses for McCook has always been that we have more to offer than other Nebraska cities our size. We have 3 movie screens, a bowling alley, video game places, 3 nice parks, fishing, hunting, golf, Frisbee golf, a new tennis complex, a great YMCA, an outdoor swimming pool, multiple nice softball and baseball fields, kids soccer programs, multiple sports, community concerts, a children's theater presentation, three libraries, 4-H, boy scouts, girl scouts, multiple church activities, the Kiplinger and all those activities and more. In fact some people have asked why it is city taxpayers responsibility to entertain other people's children. Regardless, best wishes in your new community. Hope you are more supportive to it than you are to your former community.

    -- Posted by dennis on Thu, Aug 28, 2008, at 12:40 PM
  • Dennis I respect your thoughts on the town of McCook however I don't agree with them which is fine. You must have misunderstood my thoughts on the job market in the area. I agree that there are several jobs in the paper daily, however they aren't the jobs I was talking about when I mentioned the pay or benefits. The "activities" in McCook are as you said available, however most require a large fee to participate in. The community concerts are for the much older crowd and if you are speaking of the concert that was recently held at the auditorium as a good activity for youth, then you are sadly mistaken. That was music that you could barely understand the words to and had to be brain dead to listen too in the first place. The taxes may be higher in North Platte however the community is not full of two faced people whom are more concerned about there "public image" than the type of person they are. I will take higher taxes over my child being made to feel like they were less of a person by a "upstanding resident" any day. Everyone wonders why the there are so many school shooting these days, it is directly related to the way that children are allowed to treat one another. That behavior is obviously passed down from a parent. The 'zero tolerance" policy in McCook is fake and needs to be strictly monitor. I went to McCook schools as well as worked with children whom were "troubled". I know exactly what it is like to be looked down upon by those that "have". I also saw first hand through my work that there were several occasions where kids should have been reprimanded for negative behavior, and were not due to them being a member of a certain family or were the "star athlete".

    There are many reasons why we left McCook, first and for most is the way kids are allowed to treat one another and made to feel about themselves. I didn't want any of my children to be judged for what the didn't have rather than the person they were.

    -- Posted by FormerMcCookie on Fri, Aug 29, 2008, at 6:57 PM
  • I can speak from first-hand experience; the grass is NOT any greener on the other side of the fence than it is right here. I've read every comment made in this forum regarding the city of McCook, and the surrounding area, and all the negative aspects of the community & region. I've spent the last 4+ decades in a similar-sized community on the other end of the state, and the challenges and criticisms are the same there as here.

    Some say there's nothing to do; others say not enough job opportunities. Some say taxes are too high; others reply they're just fine. I don't want to sound like Mr. Sunshine, but folks...I was given the choice between McCook and 3 other cities (some larger) to move to within my career field, and after weighing all the pro's & cons, we chose McCook...and are darn glad we did!

    If you want to sit and stew in your own juices, you'll be miserable. But if you leave your attitude at home in the closet when you do outdoors, you'll see this town has a LOT to offer with some very friendly people!

    North Platte may be bigger, with more work and shopping opportunities. But along with those additional choices are a higher crime rate, heavier traffic-laden streets, and even more alcohol and drug problems among young people than you will find elsewhere within 100 miles.

    The original responder to this thread made reference to the schools and the way they "allow" students to treat one another. I doubt this gentleman has any more kids in school than I do (5), so let me again speak in the first-person: From the day we registered our children (Kindergarten through the 6th grade), we were welcomed by a friendly staff, and met with some fine teachers. After the first full week of school, every one of my children said they couldn't have asked for a better place to learn! Two of my children require a little special consideration due to some physical challenges. The school's staff, AND the kids in their respective classes, have been absolutely wonderful! No rude comments, no teasing, no name-calling, and no bickering.

    Maybe, just maybe, there are a few adults who could take a page from these children's books!

    Just a thought...

    -- Posted by Willie B Wright on Mon, Sep 1, 2008, at 8:59 PM
  • Thanks again Mr. Wright. Life is what you make it. McCook, like all communities, has areas that need improvement. However crying that something must be done to improve it does little to make improvements. Instead people need to ask what they can do to make things better and hanging dirty laundry out in public actually hurts rather than helps. Again Mr. Wright thanks for your positive attitude!

    -- Posted by dennis on Tue, Sep 2, 2008, at 9:29 AM
Respond to this story

Posting a comment requires free registration: