Opinion

The Border Wall

Tuesday, November 13, 2018

First off a disclaimer. I have great respect of Gene O. Morris, past editor and recent prolific columnist for the Gazette. Politically Gene and I sit on opposite sides of the fence politically. I consider myself a bit conservative and vote Republican. Gene, though he has concealed it well over the years, has to be a staunch liberal, progressive, Democrat at heart. I’ll use the term liberal in an attempt to be the least divisive and I honestly don’t know how he votes. Visit with him a few minutes though and ask him his opinion of our current President Donald Trump then hang on for a wild ride as Gene pontificates about what a terrible human our president of the moment is. Satin personified!

To illustrate liberal thinking let’s turn to an opinion piece that Gene wrote and was published on November 6th titled “The Border Wall: Should it be built?”

Gene gives a beautiful description of the countryside they drove through on a little trip he took with his bride Barbara out to Yellowstone Park. Miles and miles of open country nearly devoid of people. Then a liberal conclusion that we need more people to maybe fill that open land to make America great again. We must welcome immigrants of any description because more people of diversified background can only be good. No mention that those wide open spaces are not populated because there aren’t enough resources to make a living when it takes 20 to 50 acres to support a cow-calf pair. So where would all those new immigrants live and work and produce and assimilate? A liberal identifies a perceived problem, throws out his solution and expects everyone else to support it.

A few years back Frank and Deborah Popper proposed a different solution. They wanted this area to depopulate and turn it all back to bison pasture. Buffalo Commons they thought sounded good. Well, we “deplorables” rejected the Popper’s liberal thinking and turned the term into a wonderful festival, storytelling and more, that we host annually.

Gene’s column didn’t sit well with several friends and one Corky Krizek wrote that Gene could step up and sponsor a family or two, see that they have shelter and food in his community, find them jobs and help them assimilate into our midst. Corky, you see, was speaking from experience as she led the welcoming effort of a family that escaped from Cambodia at the end of the Vietnam War. Assimilate they did to become the successful friends and neighbors we know today. Liberals don’t seem to do, they just want others to do the grunt labor to fulfill their dreams of how things should be.

Two other friends in this community wrote good articles concerning immigration. Del Harsh wrote on how the Germans of Volga Russia assimilated into this area and made it the success it is today. Helen Bieker, from Canada, also wrote of her experience in becoming a US citizen so she could vote -- needlessly long and frustratingly complicated!

As a child on our farm south of McCook during WWII, I remember German Prisoners of War working in dad’s sugar beet and potato fields. When the POW’s went home, dad contracted for Mexican nationals to come work hoeing beets and picking potatoes in a Bracero program. Those were single men coming here on work visas to do that contract labor with the expectation that they would return home to Mexico at the end of their contract. Good idea but I suspect that big labor objected and killed that effort to have economical labor through progressive lobbying efforts in Congress.

Since that time and even unto today young Hispanic men have illegally come over our southern border to work in this country. Most have no intention of staying and send money back home for the good of their families. And yes you don’t have to look very hard to find those illegals in our own community. The Democrats like to call them “undocumented immigrants”, instead of the proper term illegal aliens.

Daily on TV, we hear of caravans of Central Americans wending their way across Mexico intent on entering the US. I see estimates that about 80% of those in the caravans are single men and I suspect that their intent is sneak across the border and find jobs here just as has been going on for decades. Now the other 20% seem to be families, men and women mostly with children. That is a whole different story as those will probably ask for amnesty with the intent of migrating, staying, in this country.

The purpose of President Trump’s wall along the border then is to force all those coming to go through the ports of entry so they can be processed and tracked when they come into this country. Obviously, that system is being abused and overwhelmed. Congress is responsible for creating rules for immigration into this country and what we have now is not working as it should. It is then a crying need for Congress to do their job and tweak the system so it can have some semblance of working.

Quoting from Gene Morris’ article: “All things considered, I believe building a wall sends the wrong signal, shouting in a ‘bullying’ way to our southern neighbors that they are NOT welcome to visit or reside in the United States of America. If very clear and fair immigration rules are in place, I hereby offer to be among the first to sign a petition which strongly encourages state and federal members of the legislative and executive branches of government to prohibit the building of a wall along our nation’s southern border.”

Well, Gene, it is the US Congress that is responsible for making immigration law and the states really have little say in the matter. The President is responsible to carry out the laws duly made by Congress and his idea of a border wall, concertina razor wire works too, will just help guide all those intended immigrants to go through the port of entry and abide by our laws. Somehow the progressive (spelled Democrat) members of Congress don’t seem to want orderly to happen. I’d encourage you to sign your petition Gene to encourage your Democrat representatives to do their job instead of fighting Trump at every step of the way.

That is how I saw it.

Dick Trail

Comments
View 8 comments
Note: The nature of the Internet makes it impractical for our staff to review every comment. Please note that those who post comments on this website may do so using a screen name, which may or may not reflect a website user's actual name. Readers should be careful not to assign comments to real people who may have names similar to screen names. Refrain from obscenity in your comments, and to keep discussions civil, don't say anything in a way your grandmother would be ashamed to read.
  • There is another way of looking at this that may explain why some people , perhaps including Morris,are caravan sympathetic. Here's the issue. What if , instead of Mexicans coming to the border, there were Swedes or British or Germans trying to escape some particular hardship or deprivation and thought that they could do so by coming to the USA. How many of the people who are so against the south American caravan would oppose a white European caravan? What I'm trying to say here is that it probably isn't so much a matter of 6000 people coming from a different country to the border as it is 6000 dark skinned people coming to the border. In other words , it's very likely just a racial or racist thing. When you think about it and listen to those oppose the caravan , it really does seem to be just that.

    -- Posted by bob s on Tue, Nov 13, 2018, at 6:50 PM
  • Bob, I would be opposed regardless of race. Most nations have immigration based upon merit...what can those wanting to enter the country do for the country. Recent catch and release illegal alien statistics indicated 47% did not have even a high school diploma or equivalent. (No data on specific skill levels or higher education). This compares to 8% of legal US citizens without such. The issue then becomes if those trying to enter the US will help the US or will they be a drain on the country. Another point is that these folks if entering illegally jump of those waiting in line to legally enter.

    -- Posted by dennis on Tue, Nov 13, 2018, at 7:28 PM
  • I tend to think there is much racism involved. Most people would in some genuine way not think, for example, that educated people were more worthy of relief from some pressing hardship than were uneducated people.

    -- Posted by bob s on Wed, Nov 14, 2018, at 12:30 PM
  • I think the answer is to remove the opportunities that these humans know await them once they get into the US. Punishment s rarely mentioned for those offering these opportunities, due to the economic affects that would be encountered from punishing the employers that take full advantage of the cheap labor they take advantage of with no obligations to provide benefits such as medical insurance or pensions or even holidays along with no worries about safe working conditions. Would Nebraska dare to lead the nation in asking these companies to choose between complying with the rule of law or leaving the state if they refuse to obey the laws that are already in place. If the caravan had the intention of getting into the US in time to vote in the mid-term elections they should have started their hike much sooner!

    I will have to believe the word of Rev. Colling, who was interviewed in the attached article.

    http://www.travelingwithtwain.org/2012/01/05/general/in-the-middle-of-white-nebr...

    -- Posted by nebraskamike on Wed, Nov 14, 2018, at 2:56 PM
  • Obviously LtCol Trail (USAF Retired) has touched on " a hot button" that resonates through out the nation at this time with the Central American caravans arriving at the US southern border.

    The quote on the Statue of Liberty is the following:

    “Give me your tired, your poor,

    Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free,

    The wretched refuse of your teeming shore.

    Send these, the homeless, tempest-tossed to me,

    I lift my lamp beside the golden door!”

    The "golden door" - interesting. She does seem to agree that immigrants should be allowed to enter in an orderly manner that she refers to the "golden door". I will take the liberty to interpret this that "immigration must be an orderly process that is governed by US Immigration Laws that the US Congress writes and the Executive Branch is to enforce.

    My wife is a "chain immigrant" from the Philippines that came about through an arranged marriage. Once she came to Hawaii and became employed and an US Citizen she then started petitioning the rest of her family. It took her 5 years plus to bring over her eleven brothers and sister as well as her mother and father that hid out in the mountains of the Philippines during the occupation by the Japanese in WW II.

    These folks all became productive individuals and contributed to the nation to one degree or another. They followed the laws and earned every benefit and privilege of a legal person entering the USA. My experience in life is those that EARN benefits they seem to appreciate it much more.

    There are many examples of the US helping immigrants in need. The Vietnam War was a perfect example. Refugees were taken to camps in Guam, Texas and Philippines for processing into the USA. Processing !!

    Let's welcome those worthy of being allowed into our great country but let's do this in an orderly manner to insure they "deserve" to be in this country. It seems that the term "right" has expanded to what are actually privileges by being righteous citizens or legal immigrants.

    Yes, we need immigration to proceed to allow the "melting pot" to allow citizens of the world to achieve their potentials - but in a controlled manner for entry.

    Gene Morris has been a great supporter of the Bison project and I know he and I agree on several other issues I have faced since coming back into the area. I hope Gene and I can agree that a controlled immigration is in the best interest of the nation and SW Nebraska. Nebraska is obviously welcoming immigrants primarily in the dairy and meat processing industries.

    Sincere Regards to All .

    Darrell Meister

    -- Posted by dameister on Wed, Nov 14, 2018, at 9:13 PM
  • It's sort of interesting how Meister thinks you have to prove yourself in some way to be in America. Or that one has to show himself to be worthy of being here. " Must have potential to be productive, etc." he says. What if we were to really make that a goal in the USA. How many american citizens who are lazy, uneducated, dopers, criminals, scammers, corrupt officials, perverted clergy, or just plain worthless miscreants do you think we would have to EXPORT to achieve that goal? Why such a high bar for the new folks? The USA is wall to wall goofballs. What is he looking at here? How isolated and naive can a guy be ?

    -- Posted by bob s on Wed, Nov 14, 2018, at 11:32 PM
  • The wall has been built and no one seems to be capable of seeing it!

    -- Posted by nebraskamike on Fri, Nov 16, 2018, at 1:58 PM
  • Maybe I'm not so naive. The Mexicans are even wanting this migration or immigration without regulation needs to come to an end.

    -- Posted by dameister on Tue, Nov 20, 2018, at 12:44 AM
Respond to this story

Posting a comment requires free registration: