[mccookgazette.com] Fair ~ 61°F  
High: 63°F ~ Low: 42°F
Monday, May 2, 2016

Good intentions gone awry

Tuesday, March 1, 2011

Gov. Frank Morrison was a gent that I enjoyed visiting. I greatly respected him. I'd known Frank since high school when his son Biff (actually Frank Jr.) and I played football together. At the time, Frank was a successful attorney in McCook. Even my dad had great respect for Frank having sat on the jury of a local murder trial while Frank was the defense attorney. Dad was impressed that Frank pulled no stunts to get his guilty client off but simply portrayed him as the unsavory character that he actually was. A fair trial? You bet. The jury's decision was easy and correct and the perp went off to his just reward.

An Air Force career took me to the far reaches during the time that Frank embarked on his political career culminating as governor of the Great State of Nebraska. Years later, we spent many hours visiting at Hillcrest Nursing Home where both Frank and his beloved Maxine were residents. I went daily to spend time with my mother and he always searched me out. At the time Frank's body was growing more infirm but his mind remained sharp as a tack.

Now Frank was a dyed-in-the-wool Democrat and I a true blue Republican, but we listened to and respected each other's opinion. At the time, I was writing my usual political screed chastising local politicians for liberal- leaning actions. Frank told me that he enjoyed what I wrote and kept telling me that I should syndicate my work, whatever that means.

I vividly remember the day that Governor Frank told me why he had become a Democrat. It was during the depression of the '30s when people everywhere were hurting from the terrible economy. For many, it was a desperate struggle just to keep food on the table. Frank was looking at the efforts by President Franklin D. Roosevelt to get our economy back on track and agreed with the idea that infusion of government money could help get things moving again. And it seemed to work! New Deal farm programs gave money enough to farmers to allow them to "hold on." The CCC employed thousands of young men who had no opportunity to find a job anywhere. A bonus was the many public works projects such as the municipal auditorium that has been a center of public life over the years right here in McCook. Then, too, FDR initiated the Social Security program where monies were extracted from working men's paychecks and set-aside to be paid back to those who managed to live to the ripe old age of 65 years. Then World War II happened, the economy of the USofA revived and we never looked back.

Frank never mentioned it, but FDR and the Democrats learned something else in their efforts to break the economic doldrums of the Depression. They found that when you showered government money on the public, voters tend to show their appreciation by voting the spenders back into office. It works yet today. That is why our honorable U.S. Sen. Ben Nelson is always out front announcing how he managed to get the money, our tax money, to do some magnificent project. The latest largess to come our way is the $10 million or so allocated to fix the dam over the Medicine Creek just north of town. It used to be called "pork" but that term fell into disfavor so "earmarks" became the standard but that term is thankfully becoming tarnished. Ben issued several press releases to announce that he was putting the request for the funds for that repair into the budget request a year or so ago but I haven't heard much about it lately. "Investments" in infrastructure?

The unions found that politicians, mainly Democrats, could be influenced in their favor by spending their members' dues as campaign donations. Nothing in this world is free, so those politicians were expected to vote in turn for legislation that favored the unions. A recent example is how GM and Chrysler were "saved" from bankruptcy by using our tax dollars to bail them out. With bankruptcy the union contracts would have been set aside, the company could have been reorganized and production continued using the more reasonable labor rates paid by Toyota and others producing domestic autos.

Fortunately Nebraska was wise in passing legislation declaring that we are a "Right to Work" state. Unions are still allowed, as they should be, but they have no right to declare that all workers in their shop be union members and they have to collect their own dues.

We look at the news of the moment and see Wisconsin teachers on strike, demonstrating in and around their state house day after day. Union members across the nation, and even Jesse Jackson are front-and-center yelling and carrying signs to protest that Governor Walker is "union busting."

Yes he wants to put restrictions on the teachers' union by restricting collective bargaining, but what they don't mention is that the state of Wisconsin collects union dues from every teacher, no matter if they are members of their union or not. A large portion of union election campaign contributions, somewhere around 95 percent, have gone to Democrat candidates who return the favor by passing union-friendly legislation. The unions fear that if membership is voluntary, a large portion of the teachers will opt out and their campaign war chests will be greatly diminished. I'd opt out, too. if my union was funding a campaign for a politician that I didn't want in office! Wisconsin voters have had enough and sent a new slate of legislators to the state house to get the resulting debt under control and diminishing the power of their teacher's union is a big part of that solution.

And that is the problem with long-time earmark and unions buying political influence. They both irresponsibly spend someone else's money and the money is running out. The crisis is here and now. The liberal solution has always been to raise taxes to cover their debt. High taxes depress the economy and the public has begun to object at the ballot box. Earmarks have fallen into disfavor because an informed public figures out that we have to pay for projects that are of no benefit to us in far flung states like Sen. Murkowski's (R) Alaska. We the taxpayers have seen the light and are now demanding a stop of both practices. Thus the turmoil.

Good intentions gone bankrupt; what is a politician to do?

That is the way I saw it.

Dick Trail

Fact Check
See inaccurate information in this story?

Note: The nature of the Internet makes it impractical for our staff to review every comment. If you feel that a comment is offensive, please Login or Create an account first, and then you will be able to flag a comment as objectionable. Please also note that those who post comments on mccookgazette.com may do so using a screen name, which may or may not reflect a website user's actual name. Readers should be careful not to assign comments to real people who may have names similar to screen names. Refrain from obscenity in your comments, and to keep discussions civil, don't say anything in a way your grandmother would be ashamed to read.

While I can't speak for the way things are done in Wisconsin, in California, while one must pay either union dues and be a member or pay a service and be a non-member, the service fee paying non member pays only that percentage of regular dues that go for the actual work for the employees by the union, that portion of the union dues earmarked for political activities is not paid by service fee paying nonmembers.

In California, those who don't support the political objectives of the union representing them do not pay for the financial support for canidates they don't support.

And just where would Nebraska be if they hadn't been getting in the neighborhood of $1.20 back for every $1 Nebraskans have paid in Federal taxes for years? Nebraska traditionally has been a welfare state collecting more from the Federal government than they pay in to the Federal treasury.

-- Posted by ontheleftcoast on Wed, Mar 2, 2011, at 2:09 AM

Good article regarding your relationship with Gov Morrison went way off track with your union comments. Unions were in place before the depression and FDR didn't create collective bargaining. Looks like two articles placed in one.

-- Posted by BuffRoam on Thu, Mar 3, 2011, at 10:37 AM

1. I was always under the impression that the dam 10 miles north of McCook was "over" Red Willow Creek. Perhaps the Medicine makes a big right turn south of Curtis somewhere....??

2. If the government does not allocate the money to fix the dam, just how in the devil is it supposed to get fixed? I do not consider funds to repair the dam, pork. Or perhaps just go ahead and take a chance, fill her back up, and hope that it doesn't bust and sweep away everything in it's flood plain for miles, including I'm sure many human lives. Guess if that money is considered pork, guess I'm all for that "pork". I would think that most people that live downstream of the dam,(on I think Red Willow Creek) would also agree that the funds to repair the dam are a needed expenditure, not "pork".

-- Posted by goarmy67 on Thu, Mar 3, 2011, at 7:38 PM

And while Dick loves to beat up on Dem's spending, I just read today where 85% of our debt was acquired while three Republicans were in office. Dick, you talk about going all over the place, try a different radio station, please. Obviously with all of your savy experience in politics you are one sharp dude.. but.. make no mistake, the union thing is aimed at eliminating the Democratic party, it has nothing to do with the balancing of any budget.

-- Posted by hulapopper on Thu, Mar 3, 2011, at 8:12 PM

Mr. Trail

Now that we have had more than a few years of data comparing Right to Work States with non Right to Work States, a more definitive analysis can be made to counter your assumption that Right to Work States offer more for the workers.

Right-to-work (RTW) laws do not boost employment growth in the states in which they are enacted, a new Economic Policy Institute (EPI) Briefing Paper finds. In fact, RTW laws may actually harm a state's economic prospects.

The following link is to the Breifing Report which was just published Mar. 1, 2011.


-- Posted by Geezer on Sat, Mar 5, 2011, at 10:09 PM

Respond to this story

Posting a comment requires free registration:

Dick Trail
The Way I Saw It